Brian d'Arcy James ( Brian d'Arcy James )

Richard Damrosch

Monica Barbaro ( Monica Barbaro )

Lydia Damrosch

Hudson McGuire ( Hudson McGuire )

Jesse 3 Year Old

Henry Glendon Walter V ( Henry Glendon Walter V )

Jesse 9 Year Old

Robert Levey II ( Robert Levey II )

Jesse 12 Year Old

William Bednar-Carter ( William Bednar-Carter )

Jesse 17 Year Old

Mark Zeisler ( Mark Zeisler )

Nick Orkin

Geraldine Singer ( Geraldine Singer )

Flora Orkin

Cynthia Mace ( Cynthia Mace )

Billie Alloway

Madeline Hudelson ( Madeline Hudelson )

Kara Orkin

Siena Marino ( Siena Marino )

Young Christine Orkin

Linnea Gregg ( Linnea Gregg )

Christine Orkin

Candy Dato ( Candy Dato )

Josephine

Erich Rausch ( Erich Rausch )

Ted Alloway

Gorman Ruggiero ( Gorman Ruggiero )

Dominic

Melinda Tanner ( Melinda Tanner )

Claire

Andrea Woodbridge ( Andrea Woodbridge )

Marie

Myxolydia Tyler ( Myxolydia Tyler )

Judy

Matthew Hammond ( Matthew Hammond )

Peter McMillan

Ethan Rhys Walker ( Ethan Rhys Walker )

Andrew

Justin Albinder ( Justin Albinder )

Roy Abramsohn ( Roy Abramsohn )

Rosanne Rubino ( Rosanne Rubino )

Jean

Cooper Carrell ( Cooper Carrell )

Young Andrew

Steven Alonte ( Steven Alonte )

John Menlo

Jackie Krim ( Jackie Krim )

Talia Menlo

Mark Mitton ( Mark Mitton )

Diane Mostello ( Diane Mostello )

Mary

William Day ( William Day )

Caroline Luft ( Caroline Luft )

Amy Scanlon ( Amy Scanlon )

The Clown

John Lange ( John Lange )

Christopher Ballard ( Christopher Ballard )

Ally Callaghan ( Ally Callaghan )

Chris Felicio ( Chris Felicio )

Michael Kohlbrenner ( Michael Kohlbrenner )

Graham Swon ( Graham Swon )

Daniel Ryniker ( Daniel Ryniker )

Deanna Manno ( Deanna Manno )

Salvador Franzese ( Salvador Franzese )

Madeleine James ( Madeleine James )

Narrator (voice)