Val Kilmer ( Val Kilmer )

Hall Baltimore

Bruce Dern ( Bruce Dern )

Sheriff Bobby LaGrange

Elle Fanning ( Elle Fanning )

V.

Ben Chaplin ( Ben Chaplin )

Edgar Allan Poe

Joanne Whalley ( Joanne Whalley )

Denise

David Paymer ( David Paymer )

Sam

Anthony Fusco ( Anthony Fusco )

Pastor Allan Floyd

Alden Ehrenreich ( Alden Ehrenreich )

Flamingo

Bruce A. Miroglio ( Bruce A. Miroglio )

Deputy Arbus

Don Novello ( Don Novello )

Melvin

Lisa Bailes ( Lisa Bailes )

Ruth

Ryan Simpkins ( Ryan Simpkins )

Caroline

Lucas Rice Jordan ( Lucas Rice Jordan )

P. J.

Fiona Medaris ( Fiona Medaris )

Vicky

Katie Crom ( Katie Crom )

Circe

Tom Waits ( Tom Waits )

Narrator (voice)

Stacey Mattina ( Stacey Mattina )

Lorraine Gaudet ( Lorraine Gaudet )

Dorothy Tchelistcheff ( Dorothy Tchelistcheff )

Lucy Bunter ( Lucy Bunter )

Kristine Hayworth ( Kristine Hayworth )

Marisa Lenhardt ( Marisa Lenhardt )

Davia Schendel ( Davia Schendel )