Samantha Robinson ( Samantha Robinson )

Elaine

Gian Keys ( Gian Keys )

Griff

Laura Waddell ( Laura Waddell )

Trish

Jeffrey Vincent Parise ( Jeffrey Vincent Parise )

Wayne

Jared Sanford ( Jared Sanford )

Gahan

Robert Seeley ( Robert Seeley )

Richard

Jennifer Ingrum ( Jennifer Ingrum )

Barbara

Randy Evans ( Randy Evans )

Steve

Clive Ashborn ( Clive Ashborn )

Professor King

Lily Holleman ( Lily Holleman )

Miss Curtis

Jennifer Couch ( Jennifer Couch )

Wendy

Stephen Wozniak ( Stephen Wozniak )

Jerry

April Showers ( April Showers )

Herself

Giselle DaMier ( Giselle DaMier )

Harpist

Elle Evans ( Elle Evans )

Star

Fair Micaela Griffin ( Fair Micaela Griffin )

Moon

Dani Lennon ( Dani Lennon )

Mandy (Barmaid)

Gina Venditti ( Gina Venditti )

Jane (Barmaid)

Frank Farmer ( Frank Farmer )

Sam (Bartender)

Kyle Derek ( Kyle Derek )

Lyle

Alisha Honoré ( Alisha Honoré )

Connie

Christopher LeCrenn ( Christopher LeCrenn )

Jester

Neil Gillen ( Neil Gillen )

Troubadour

Amy Segal ( Amy Segal )

Lady Love

Jacob Peacock ( Jacob Peacock )

Holly King

Ron Kari ( Ron Kari )

Oak King

Robert Michael Anderson ( Robert Michael Anderson )

Sun Dancer

Jacklyn Chung-Young ( Jacklyn Chung-Young )

Sun Dancer

Larva ( Larva )

Barry Morse ( Barry Morse )

Male Witch

Max Carson ( Max Carson )

Lily Abrams ( Lily Abrams )

Jonathan Knight ( Jonathan Knight )

Casey Larios ( Casey Larios )

Amanda Stoer ( Amanda Stoer )

Michael G. Gabel ( Michael G. Gabel )

Musician (as Michael Gabel)

Michael Davis ( Michael Davis )

Jonathan Beck ( Jonathan Beck )

Rachel Huggins ( Rachel Huggins )

Bernard Bullen ( Bernard Bullen )

Renaissance Lord

Kaye L. Morris ( Kaye L. Morris )

Renaissance Maiden

Christian Smith ( Christian Smith )

Bridget Albaugh ( Bridget Albaugh )

Vlad Varro ( Vlad Varro )

Lisa Davis ( Lisa Davis )

Jillian Smalley ( Jillian Smalley )

Rosie Woodward ( Rosie Woodward )

Jamie Nelson ( Jamie Nelson )

Giovanni V. Giusti ( Giovanni V. Giusti )

Jeremiah Benjamin ( Jeremiah Benjamin )

Annie Newton ( Annie Newton )

Matthew Jablonsky ( Matthew Jablonsky )

R. Brian Falkner ( R. Brian Falkner )

Marilyn Winkle ( Marilyn Winkle )

Jolly Goodfellow ( Jolly Goodfellow )

Donna Madach ( Donna Madach )

Elise Massa ( Elise Massa )

Stephen Dudro ( Stephen Dudro )

Jonathan Peacy ( Jonathan Peacy )

Margaret Baker ( Margaret Baker )

Mary Russell ( Mary Russell )

Rage Stewart ( Rage Stewart )

Taryn Nicole Piana ( Taryn Nicole Piana )

Natalie Turner ( Natalie Turner )

Lucas DiMedio ( Lucas DiMedio )

Emma Rose ( Emma Rose )

Josh Connor ( Josh Connor )

Tony Ketchum ( Tony Ketchum )

David Winograd ( David Winograd )

Elaine's Dad (voice)