Laurence Olivier ( Laurence Olivier )

Priest

Julie Harris ( Julie Harris )

Maria (Priest's Mistress)

George C. Scott ( George C. Scott )

Police Lieutenant

Martin Gabel ( Martin Gabel )

Chief of Police

Roddy McDowall ( Roddy McDowall )

Mestizo

Keenan Wynn ( Keenan Wynn )

Wine Merchant

Patty Duke ( Patty Duke )

Coral

Lou Antonio ( Lou Antonio )

Val Avery ( Val Avery )

Beryl Bernay ( Beryl Bernay )

Santiago Burgos ( Santiago Burgos )

Linda Canby ( Linda Canby )

Brigida

Leonardo Cimino ( Leonardo Cimino )

Frank Conroy ( Frank Conroy )

Padre José

Steve Curry ( Steve Curry )

Cyril Cusack ( Cyril Cusack )

Tench

Roger De Koven ( Roger De Koven )

Mildred Dunnock ( Mildred Dunnock )

Spinster

Thomas Gomez ( Thomas Gomez )

Delgado

Martha Greenhouse ( Martha Greenhouse )

Rose Gregorio ( Rose Gregorio )

Gerald Hiken ( Gerald Hiken )

Arthur Hughes ( Arthur Hughes )

Mark Lenard ( Mark Lenard )

Joanna Merlin ( Joanna Merlin )

Jeremiah Morris ( Jeremiah Morris )

Dino Narizzano ( Dino Narizzano )

Mildred Natwick ( Mildred Natwick )

Tim O'Connor ( Tim O'Connor )

Florence Stanley ( Florence Stanley )

Fritz Weaver ( Fritz Weaver )

Louis Zorin ( Louis Zorin )

James Coco ( James Coco )

Soldier (uncredited)